Skip to main content

Look how far we've come

The recent shooting in Tuscon has the nation asking the question - has the political dialogue gone too far? 

Unless you've been completely isolated from the media and Internet, then you know the answer is a resounding YES! As a nation we seem to have lost the ability to tolerate divergent opinions. There is an attitude of "you're either with me or against me" - it appears to be all black and white. The party politics in Washington has been like a rapidly spreading virus leaving the Beltway and coming to cities and towns all across the nation. In the not so distant past, we could tolerate people that were more liberal or conservative than us. We might have intelligent conversations or even slightly heated debates. On the airwaves, we saw or heard news stories related to politics and on that rare occasion we would hear opinions. Remember the 60 Minutes segment where two individuals (I believe it was always the same man and woman) would each give their opinion on a particular topic? It spawned a parody on Saturday Night Live with Jane Curtin and Chevy Chase. 

Anyway, I digress. In more recent times, our 'news' is 24/7 - and there are more than 3 networks vying for our time and attention. In addition to the big three networks, we now have exclusive 'news' stations like FOX, MSNBC and CNN. There is a whole lot of time to fill and only so much real news with which to fill it - so we get a broad spectrum of 'news' shows all with a particular angle or bent. Sadly, we as a public have soaked up these 'news' shows and believe what is said as truth. While there may be kernels of truth in all that we hear, there is always more opinion than fact.

Way back in the day (don't I sound old now!) when I majored in journalism, the primary lesson learned in nearly every class was to be unbiased and to write from that point of view. We were taught that the reading or listening public should never be able to discern a writer's particular stance on any story's topic. It was challenging but it was doable. We were taught that there was the editorial page or, if on radio or TV time devoted to editorials that were clearly delineated from the news. I find it difficult to find the distinction on today's networks and cable stations.

The rhetoric has gone too far - and there is far too much of it.

These days when I watch morning news programs, I tune in to Morning Joe on MSNBC because there is always of round table of people with very different opinions on a variety of topics and they have civilized discussions. There are Republicans and Democrats talking - not shouting - and even more important, listening to one another. Refreshing.  I cannot watch Glenn Beck or Keith Olberman - they often seem to be espousing fact when there 'facts' were pulled from I don't know where. But they are popular - people watch and believe.

Many years ago when Rush Limbaugh was new to the airwaves I remember discussing with my husband that Rush was dangerous because he spoke eloquently and assertively about topics and often his 'facts' were wrong. If a caller pointed this out - he was shot down and often ridiculed. Well these days,  Rush is the template from which all others draw their broadcast creations. As we witnessed last Saturday in Tuscon, the result of these political diatribes is dangerous. We don't know for sure if the shooter was acting on some political agenda, but we are finally having discussions about controlling our messages and taming the violence in our debates.

We have 500 stations to watch with cable and satellite. We have as many to listen to with satellite radio. Look how far we've come. More importantly, look how far we have to go to, once again, to become a thinking, civilized humanity. We need to learn to once again delineate the news from the opinions. Our politicians need to once again learn to have respectful debates and quit toeing the party lines. And we need to focus on our common goals and not on our differences.

For our children and the next generation, we need to change the course of this country.

Comments

  1. A real distinction that can be made by viewers...if they would do it...is that the 'old' media tv and radio outlets are regulated (not controlled...regulated) by the FCC. They are required to attempt to offer NEWS. That means they must report facts. Cable news is under no such regulation and can do what it chooses. This makes a real difference.

    Agree with the 'common goals'. I would add that we need to find and promote leaders...then reward them...for looking out for the COMMON GOOD...a lost concept with elected officials at state and federal level right now.

    We are talking about reversing a cultural direction that we have been going for some time. Difficult, complex, and even more challenging when we would all like to have SIMPLE answers.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

It's not a popularity contest, but ...

Parenting

I just read a post on Facebook regarding the dearth of parenting. The poster was describing a scene where two young girls were pelting rocks at some ducks in our little town and how he observed no parents around telling these girls that it was wrong to torture little innocent animals. Within hours, there were 15 responses - all alluding to a lack of parenting that is evident nearly everywhere today. Stick with me here - because that conversation reminded me of one I'd had recently that might not seem related to parenting at all. It was with my oldest son about his concern about the selfishness of our culture - most recently evident in the Wall Street meltdown. He believes that we are too focused on "Me" and not enough on "We" and if we had a little more focus on the total and just not our part, we would be in a much better place. Still there? Okay, here's the cement that will hold this together - those girls pelting little ducks with rocks weren't likely...

When a small town is huge

  In the movie "it's a Wonderful Life", the protagonist George Bailey has longed nearly his whole life to 'shake off the dust of this crummy little town off my feet," to see the world. But Bedford Falls, that crummy little town, felt differently about George. And with the help of a quirky guardian angel, George eventually sees that his life and his town were pretty wonderful. Good lord, but I love that movie and it's characters and it's moral and that small town. I watch it every year at least twice and still cry every time. And I wonder too about the man that pushes the devious Mr. Potter's wheelchair and stands by his side- you know the man, he looks a little like Lurch from "The Addams Family". I wonder, what was he thinking as he listened and watched his boss ruin the lives of everyone he could. What kind of an Non-disclosure agreement did he sign, to keep him silent as he stood by and watched Potter pocket the money Uncle Billy was depo...

When you encounter a totally different reality

John and I arrived early for an appointment (for those of you that know my husband, you know that this is not infrequent! The story of arriving three hours early for a flight to Phoenix from Midway still gets repeated and laughed about when the 'kids' get together). We found a seat and the waiting room began to fill. We had chosen seats away from the TV where NBC's Today Show was playing, so we couldn't see what was on the screen. Another couple sat before the TV and provided commentary and as the time progressed provided a glimpse into a total different 'reality'. "Oh I can't even stand to look at him. He's so evil" "What is wrong with his hair?" "This administration will do down in history as the worst ever." "The federal government is taking over the states. There's going to be a civil war, just you wait." "They just let all those illegal aliens in and then they're going to give them weapons to take...